Blog

EU Realises Its Stupidity And Defers Cookie Law For 1 Year

by

This has been a real bug bear of mine for some time now, today the EU cookie law was meant to come into force – and low and behold, nothing.

The only site I have seen asking explicit permission for storing cookies prior to placing a cookie is – well, nobody. The ICO website actually places a session cookie without asking – why? I’m not sure, it doesn’t seem absolutely necessary unless I was to tick the box saying I accept cookies!!! It’s not like I’m going to login or add any EU directives to some fictional shopping cart. So ICO, why the “necessary” cookie?

To be fair though, I’ve been stuggling to think up an ideal solution and I think their’s is it. But you can tell people have struggled with this – I haven’t been able to find any possible solutions being blogged about (maybe there are some, but I couldn’t find them).

On the BBC News today they have announced that the cookie law is to be deferred for a year, but if they receive a complaint and the business hasn’t displayed evidence for trying to work towards a solution then they may be in trouble.

So, which websites do we think will be adhering to the legislation?

How about, Amazon.co.uk?

Nope.

Ok, ok, how about Google.co.uk?

Nope.

How about legislation.gov.uk, surely the website that lays down the law itself would adhere tothe law?

Nope.

To be honest, this along with the G8 thing on controlling the Internets is really starting to put me off us being in the EU – at the moment all I can see is our economy faultering where other economies such as the US economy prospering. We’re in a bad enough situation as it is, not having a Google/Facebook/Ebay/Amazon/Twitter etc. of our own, without all this legal crap stifling innovation.

12 Comments

  • Rob 729 days ago

    The ICO site actually has a better/more elegant solution than I expected, however it will certainly still deter some people from using a site entirely! Quite amazed that not a single one of the large sites has actually done anything yet!

    I’m going to see if I can get a WordPress plugin made to create a similar solution to the ICO site – mainly just so I can use Google Analytics with ‘permission’…

    Reply
    • James Fletcher 729 days ago

      http://www.CentraStage.com

      Hi Rob,

      I’d be interested in that also.

      Cheers

      Reply
      • Rob 729 days ago

        Hi James – it’s on the cards (pretty early stages but I don’t think it’ll be too complicated!) I’ll let you know of the progress and give you a shout once it’s complete or post back here with a link if I can…

        Reply
    • Andy Dutson 729 days ago

      http://www.firstfound.co.uk

      You will get permission if the tick box is checked and submitted but you will lose all referrer data i.e. the traffic will be referred from your own domain.

      Reply
  • Sam Jarvis 729 days ago

    http://webintegrations.co.uk

    It’s a joke of a law, the amount of reprogramming and maintenance ALL web companies in the EU would have to do would be crippling, especially for smaller companies which could really do without the extra (unnecessary) load.

    Funny, http://www.ico.gov.uk/ is currently down. 4chan flexing again?

    Reply
    • David Whitehouse 729 days ago

      Hi Sam, it’s up for us!

      Reply
      • Sam Jarvis 729 days ago

        http://webintegrations.co.uk

        Oh, back now, irony averted :)

        Reply
  • [...] EU Realises Its Stupidity And Defers Cookie Law For 1 Year [...]

  • genite 729 days ago

    http://www.genite.com

    Really it is the fact.

    Reply
  • Ben 723 days ago

    http://www.clicproject.com

    I heard about this cookie law and went off to do some research on the ICO website, here are my conclusions as to the postion of the ICO:

    1- For no discernable reason, cookies are now banned, as we have been told they are evil things, and bad for privacy. We want internet users to be scared of cookies. You must tell users about the cookies you set on your site, and obtain a users consent, even though they have absolutely no idea what a cookie is.

    2- You must have a pop up box, or get them to check the privacy policy about cookies in order to comply with the law.

    3- We strongly suggest you do not use a pop up box to gain consent, as this will destroy user experience. We also do not recommend just adding this into the privacy policy, as nobody reads them.

    4 We understand that it is utterly impractical to comply with the law, and in most cases downright impossible. In these cases, it is sufficient to show that you at least tried to do something about it.

    Utter farce. They can stick their legislation.

    Reply
  • Casino Barred 719 days ago

    http://www.howtobeatthecasinos.com

    I’m glad this silly law isn’t in place for a while. It will have knock on affects for casino affiliates etc (in fact, affiliates of any product or service) as many schemes pay out based on say a 30 day cookie, or 45 day cookie record etc. Worth consideration I feel.

    Reply
  • Andy Kinsey 660 days ago

    http://andykinsey.co.uk

    the law makes some sense, i dont like really having adverts thrown at me just because i visited a given website… but I also dont think anyone believes they should have to give permission to be used for statistics, even across several websites (such as the Smashing Magazine Network of blogs) … it’s also all a bit backwards in the way it is being done … maybe it should be opt out not opt in to be tracked…

    hopefully there will be a cover-all in browsers soon.

    Reply

Write your comment

Optional

The Bronco Family
Work With Us